chase the dream not the competition

Over 1000+ articles, updated everyday...for Free SMS Alerts click here , Engineering Q&A forum here

Invite Friends
Search:     Advanced Search
Browse by category:

Bad to worse: In IIT with just 5% in JEE physics - TOI

Vist the new KnowledgeBin forum to ask all your questions! SMS Registration

Click Here to Register Online

Creative Commons License is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.

NEW DELHI: In the IIT joint entrance examination of 2007, a score of 15% in mathematics was enough to make it to IIT-Kanpur. If you found that shocking, look at this year's figures. In 2008, students could join IIT-Kharagpur despite scoring no more than 5% in physics.

For the second year running, the reduction of subject cutoffs to single digits under a procedure introduced in 2007 has allowed less meritorious candidates to slip into IITs even in the general category.

Image Hosted by

This flies in the face of the seemingly reassuring statistics put out by IIT-Roorkee on its website in August stating that in the 2008 JEE conducted by it, the marks obtained by the last admitted candidate in the general category were 63 out of 162 in maths (39%), 72 in physics (44%) and 45 in chemistry (28%).

The website glossed over the fact that some of the admitted candidates who obtained higher aggregates (and, therefore, higher ranks) actually scored much lower marks in one or the other subject than those scored by the last admitted candidate.

The lowest marks in individual subjects among the candidates admitted to IITs this year are 10 in maths (6%), 8 in physics (5%) and 15 in chemistry (9%), an RTI query has revealed.

Image Hosted by

Consider a sample of the anomalies that have emerged from the latest JEE following the drop in subject cutoffs (the first filter in the selection process) to 5 in maths, 0 in physics and 3 in chemistry.

* If the last admitted candidate had an all-India rank (AIR) of 6,773 scoring respectable percentages in all three subjects, the one who scored just 6% in maths obtained a much better AIR, 5,308, which was good enough to get him admission to IIT-Kharagpur or Roorkee.

* The candidate who scored just 5% in physics attained an AIR of 4,999, which could get him into IIT-Kharagpur, Guwahati or Roorkee, missing out on Kanpur by 3 marks and Bombay by 6 marks.

* The candidate who scored 9% in chemistry obtained an AIR of 2,903, which could help him join any of the more sought after IITs.

Image Hosted by

Several such anomalies have come to light because of the data disclosed by IIT-Roorkee in response to the RTI application from a computer sciences professor in IIT Kharagpur, Rajeev Kumar.

Though the subject cutoffs in the much-touted JEE have been in single digits since 2007 (as reported first in TOI), the compromise in the quality of intake has worsened this year. A comparison of the lowest marks obtained by admitted candidates in individual subjects shows a drop across the board in these two years (see Table I).

If such ridiculously low marks have been fetching IIT seats in the last two years, it is because, under the procedure introduced in 2007, the subject cutoffs are 20 percentile, which means the best marks obtained by the bottom 20% of the candidates in each subject.

The 2007 procedure followed IIT Kharagpur's embarrassment before the Central Information Commission because of its inability to explain the basis for the much higher subject cutoffs in the previous year's JEE, which had been conducted by it. Adopted as it was on the rebound, the 2007 procedure adopting 20 percentile as subject cutoffs has turned out to be imprudent as there was no dearth of candidates in 2008, for instance, scoring much higher marks in each subject (see Table II).

Since JEE involves negative marking, the 20 percentile formula has yielded single-digit cutoffs which have opened scope for candidates performing disastrously in one of the subjects being admitted on the strength of their marks in the other two. This has proved to be unfair to those who performed consistently in all the three subjects and yet lost out simply because their aggregates were slightly less.

From the data that is available on all three JEEs held since RTI came into force, IITs could have easily averted such incongruities in their admission procedure had they taken the subject cutoffs as the least marks of the top 20% candidates instead of the highest marks of the bottom 20% candidates (see Table III).

This is because when the 80 percentile formula is applied to the data of the last three years, the subject cutoffs turn out to be more meaningful (as they range from 21 to 37 marks) and at the same time they yield more than enough candidates to be included in the AIR list on the basis of their aggregates (since about 8,000 are currently ranked, IITs will have almost three times that many to choose from).

Given their global reputation, IITs would do well to rationalize their cutoff procedure for the 2009 JEE in the light of the anomalies that have surfaced in the last two years with the 20 percentile formula.

Source: Times Of

SMS Alerts

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Admission Updates

KnowledgeBin Forum Invite Friends

KnowledgeBin Forum Discuss In Forum

Views: 2733
Votes: 1

Others In This Category
document IIT-JEE Exam Datesheet
document Good Books For IITJEE
document IIT-JEE 2008 Syllabus
document IIT - JEE 2008 NOTICE
document The Right Book Selection For IIT - JEE and AIEEE
document New Review Of Good Books for AIEEE AND IIT - JEE
document Changes in IITJEE - Reasons & Impact
document Why the the change in pattern of IIT-JEE?
document Ranking Procedure For IIT -JEE 2008
document IIT - JEE 2008 Important Exam Dates
document IIT Entrance Exam on 13th (NEWS- IIT-D Prof speaks about it)
document IIT-JEE cut-offs fell to single digits in 2007
document Preparation For IITJEE Maths 2008 - Last Moment Tips!
document Preparation For IITJEE Chemistry 2008 - Last Moment Tips!
document IIT - JEE 2008 : Are You Prepared??
document Examination Strategies For IIT JEE
document IITJEE 2008 SOLUTIONS For Paper 1 & 2 for Various Codes
document IITJEE 2008 Cutoff, Analysis & Expected Rank
document Expected Rank In IITJEE 2008 On The Basis of JEE 2007
document IIT JEE cut-off may fall a bit in 2008
document IITJEE 2008 results to be declared on 30th May 2008
document India's top 20 engineering colleges - By
document Opening and Closing Ranks of IIT JEE 2007 courses allotted to General, SC and ST Candidates
document Availability of Courses In IIT Bombay, Delhi, Guwahati, Kanpur, Kharagpur, Madras, Roorkee, IT-BHU Varanasi, ISM Dhanbad
document IIT - JEE Branch Cut-off list of the 2007 admissions
document IITJEE Simplified: Study Tip 1 - How much should I study?
document IITJEE Simplified : Study Tip 2 - Things I should avoid?
document IITJEE Simplified : Tip 3 - What is the best way to study Mathematics?
document IIT - JEE Examination Schedule - 2009
document [NEWS] Model Answer Paper to be Available for Public Scrutiny Before Papers are Corrected
document FAQs On IIT-JEE - Questions You Generally ASK!!
document How to apply for IIT - JEE 2009? (Online/Offline)
document IIT - JEE 2009 Detailed Admission Notification (Admission Forms)
document IIT - JEE 2009 Syllabus (Chemistry, Physics & Maths)
document The EASIEST way to crack the TOUGHEST EXAM - The IIT JEE
document IIT JEE 2009 Solutions by Brilliant-Tutorials, FIITJEE, Narayana, Resonance, Prerna, Vidyamandir, Bansal, Career Launcher, Time and Career Point
document A Complete Analysis of the IIT-JEE
document IIT-JEE 2009 Cutoff, Analysis, Open and Closing Ranks of Admitted students
document IITs change Admission Procedure from JEE 2009
document IIT-JEE 2009 Results Declared - Result, Extended Merit List and Toppers
document IIT-JEE Counseling Brochure Tips and Tricks
document JEE Book recommended by Bansal Classes
document IITJEE 2010 Exam Schedule
document Class XII Marks May Play A Crucial Factor in IIT-JEE from 2011
About Us | Contact Us | Feedback | Copyright © 2008™ All rights reserved